Battista “Benny” Geritano is a long time Gambino Family Associate and a real tough guy who comes from a long line of wiseguys. He once had a problem with a young made guy from the Lucchese Family. The guy came to see him and the guy started telling him he had better watch the way he spoke. Benny looked at him and said, “Why? Who are you? You got guns? I got guns. Get lost.” This is how Benny felt towards guys who for one reason or another got inducted into a family and then thought they could throw their weight around. He would respect you if you were a tough guy and laugh in your face if you were not, regardless of your status.
Alphonse "Allie Shades" Malangone was a Capo for the Genovese Family and a huge money maker. He ran the Fulton Fish market and controlled a lot of the private carting industry. He also had restaurants and nightclubs in Brooklyn. His status as a money maker never stopped Benny from messing with Allie Shades’ girlfriend, Margo. He was told to stop and he kept it up. Allie Shades banned him from the Brooklyn night spots Pastels and Turquoise. Benny didn't care and he would show up at the clubs anyway with the rest of his friends until the guys running the clubs would beg his friends to leave so they wouldn’t have trouble. Margo and Benny eventually had a falling out and she ran to Allie Shades, who went to the Gambinos for a sit down over it. Nothing happened to Benny though.
Benny’s stepfather Anthony "Shorty" Mascuzzio was once one of John Gotti’s inner circle. That is, until he went to shakedown Bedrox (a Mid-town disco) where he began pistol whipping the owner who then took his gun away from him and shot him dead. Benny’s stepbrother, Anthony Mascuzzio Junior is a Gambino who went away until this year for being part of a marijuana trafficking group. He also used a baseball bat on some black thugs that tried to steal his Rolex once.
Preston J. Geritano was Benny’s uncle and a Genovese associate. He was stabbed to death by his brother-in-law, Genovese mobster Andy Gargiulo, aka Andy Wilson, in front of Amici’s in Brooklyn.
Preston J. Geritano Junior was arrested for money laundering.
Benny was part of what would be called the Night Drop Crew by the Feds. The crew robbed banks by prying open the night deposit boxes and taking the deposits. They developed remote controlled drills and used fishing gaffs to retrieve the cash.
They all had walkie talkies and police scanners. They got away with it from 1993 to 2003.
Benny ended up with a 71 month sentence for his part in the 10 year crime spree.
He went away and did his time. He was busted for smoking weed when his urine test came back dirty.
An FBI Agent testified at his parole hearing that he was a suspect in four separate murders.
Then Benny got into a fight in April of 2011 on Court Street in Brooklyn with Mark Iacono, owner of Lucali pizzeria. He was soon stabbing him on the sidewalk until both men were bloody. Benny took off from the scene and was later found at a hospital with stab wounds including some in his back. Benny and Mark both declined to press charges or testify in front of a grand jury. Benny however did tell the court during his parole hearing some strange stuff. He told the court he had been a Gambino associate and that members of a crime family wanted him dead. He then told the court that he was trying to go straight.
The same FBI agent who claimed he was the suspect in four murders told the court that Benny was also a suspect in a bank burglary in Bensonhurst Brooklyn that took place over a holiday weekend.
The FBI had him under surveillance but failed to keep track of him.
Benny managed to get away with that stabbing but he was soon in trouble again. This time on the night of December 23, 2012 he went to Nouveau bar in Brooklyn. He must have been in a foul mood because when a guy named Nunzio Fusco bumped into him Benny went crazy. Nunzio apologized to him and went to the bar for some drinks. Benny followed him and Nunzio told him again he was sorry and did not want any trouble. Benny shoved Nunzio’s girlfriend and Nunzio jumped to her defense. Benny and Nunzio were soon trading punches until bouncers broke it up. Benny took off and Nunzio noticed he was bleeding. He had been stabbed three times. Twice in the gut and once in the shoulder. Detectives went to the bar owner who turned over a video of the incident. The video showed Benny with the knife. A few days after turning over the video to the police the bar owner was shot on Staten Island. He lived but he claims to not have seen the shooter.
Benny went to trial on the stabbing charges and was found guilty. The judge gave him 12 years in prison. He will be be 50 when he gets out and he will still be plenty tough.